Sun 13 Nov 2005
HYD
Posted by novembreskye under My So Called Life
[7] Comments
I watched episode 3 of Hana Yori Dango. Such bad acting in HYD. I think that Nanako Matushima who plays Tsubaki is the only really truly good one in the whole cast. The chemistry is so lacking between all the players. Lots of the scenes and acting make me cringe. But when all is said and done, I still find it amusing to watch.
I can’t watch it though while thinking about the manga otherwise it makes me crazy. It’s so unlike the original storyline and some of the characters are so out of character. I realize they have to condense things but really it’s kind of annoying. Combining characters into one, deleting what I think were key characters that affected their relationship. I think it could have been handled better.
Shun is the worst. I think the casting agent made a mistake in the casting of this drama. I think Jun is best only when he’s acting in a scene with Nanako. Maybe she brings out the best in him then. He does have his moments here and there but if I were to compare to the manga he’s also just not what I pictured Tsukasa to be. I also really don’t think this drama is developing the relationship Tsukasa has with Makino fast enough. It seemed more about Rui and Makino. I guess maybe episode 4 on should move it forward faster since Rui will be out of the picture.
And
November 13th, 2005 at 12:47 pm
lol totally cool~~ i respect that a lot of people don’t find appeal in it, especially after browsing through several chinese forums as well. at least you back up your opinion with reasons for why you don’t like it. a lot of ppl are just like ‘eww f4′s ugly. this drama sucks’.
but just as a rebuttal, the characters do differ a bit from the manga characters, but imo i thought it was because they were being developed too fast. for example, for the end of episode 3, tsukasa was incredibly ooc at the airport, but they needed to show tsukushi a soft side of him, so that the last scene would work!! they had to use every scene as efficiently as they could, cos the drama is only nine episodes long, and if they’re going to be squishing 36 volumes down into nine, it’s inevitable that there’ll be some differences. i also thought the acting was fine, particularly if you compare it to the tw meteor garden a few years back.
i liked h2 actually, cept for the last episode, which i actually thought was more the script-writers’ fault, because they practically squished all the romance into that one ep =__= but yamada takayuki got a lot of my love from h2.
watch nobuta wo produce~ it’s a great drama!! =D sorry for spamming your journal =p
November 13th, 2005 at 12:50 pm
oh btw, nanako plays tsubaki. this other actress plays shizuka…
November 13th, 2005 at 3:19 pm
I love the HYD drama and Im pretty unbiased as I never read/watched any of the manga or anime/live action shows. Oh and nobuta is pretty good too, though the first ep is a little dumb.
November 13th, 2005 at 5:58 pm
I totally meant to say tsubaki… let me edit it lol.
November 13th, 2005 at 6:04 pm
I guess I don’t think they have to squish the whole story in there. They should pick and choose the scenes that were most relevant. I think it’s doable.
I liked the last episode of H2 lol. Although you’re right, I did think Haruka got the raw end of the deal – they really didn’t develop the romance between the two enough. That part was a bit unbelievable…
November 13th, 2005 at 6:07 pm
I can’t believe you came into the channel to tell me this lol… It was good to see you though anyway. Drop by more often now that you don’t have good anime to watch lol.
So here are our drama profiles:
Mine
Artemis
Maria’s
Maria’s is the only one with reviews though so you might want to look at hers. I haven’t gotten around to reviews yet.
November 13th, 2005 at 8:03 pm
you all gave ‘sekai no chuushin de ai o sakebu’ high scores. i never finished watching it because i couldn’t sleep at night, because everything was done in such a heartwrenchingly realistic way. haha i’d be a total emotional wreck at the end, so i still haven’t been able to finish it yet =__=